How USA Hockey Has Failed in Coaching Education – And What Needs to Change

Introduction: Teaching Coaches Without Teaching Them How to Teach

USA Hockey has long been the governing body for hockey development in the U.S., setting the framework for coaching education and player development. But despite its efforts, the system has a glaring flaw—it fails to educate coaches on how kids actually learn.

Instead of focusing on how to teach, communicate, and build relationships, USA Hockey's coaching education system:
❌ Overemphasizes systems and drills without teaching how to engage players.
❌ Fails to incorporate modern educational research on learning and development.
❌ Lacks meaningful instruction on how to connect with and inspire kids.

Hockey coaches aren’t just teaching skills—they’re shaping young minds, building confidence, and creating lifelong learners. It’s time for a culture shift in how we train coaches.

1️. USA Hockey’s Outdated Approach to Coaching Education

USA Hockey’s coaching certification program follows a structured level system (Level 1-5) designed to provide a foundation for coaching at different age levels. However, the curriculum is flawed in three major ways:

1. It Focuses Too Much on Systems, Not Learning Methods

• Coaches talk about X’s and O’s, forechecks, and power plays—but not how to teach those concepts effectively.

• There is little discussion about how players process information, how long they can focus, or how to engage them in learning.

📌 What’s Missing? How to communicate with kids at different ages. A 10-year-old doesn’t learn the same way as a 16-year-old—yet USA Hockey doesn’t provide coaching tools based on cognitive development.

2. It Teaches Drills, But Not How to Teach

• USA Hockey’s materials emphasize structured drills, but they don’t explain how to break them down, modify them, or teach them in a way that helps different types of learners.

• There’s not nearly enough focus on how to give feedback or how to check for understanding.

📌 What’s Missing? Coaches need to learn how to coach—not just what to coach. They need to know how to teach skills effectively, how to connect with different learning styles, and how to make sure players actually understand what’s being taught.

Drills on the internet are endless. What isn’t endless? Actual education on how to educate. It’s time we develop coaches as teachers, there are enough resources to help them design a drill.

3. It Lacks Emphasis on Building Relationships & Player Confidence

• Kids don’t learn from coaches they don’t trust. Relationships matter just as much as drills.

• USA Hockey’s coaching program provides little training on how to communicate with kids, build confidence, and foster a positive team culture.

• Great teachers connect with their students first, then educate. Why aren’t we teaching coaches how to do the same?

📌 What’s Missing? Emotional intelligence, communication strategies, and relationship-building. If coaches don’t understand how to connect with players, their technical knowledge doesn’t matter.

2️. What USA Hockey Can Learn from Education

The world of education has already figured out how to teach effectively. It’s time for USA Hockey to learn from what works in the classroom and apply it to coaching.

1. Understanding How Kids Learn

📚 In education, we know that:
✅ Kids can only focus for 10-15 minutes at a time.
✅ Learning sticks when kids are engaged and actively participating.
✅ Different students have different learning styles (visual, auditory, kinesthetic).

🏒 How this should apply to coaching:
✅ Shorter, more focused teaching moments instead of long speeches at the whiteboard.
✅ Interactive coaching—ask players questions, involve them in discussions.
✅ Teach in multiple ways—show drills visually, explain them clearly, and let players physically walk through them.

2. Differentiated Instruction – Not Every Player Learns the Same Way

📚 In education, teachers adjust instruction to fit different learners.
🏒 In hockey, coaches should do the same.

Instead of forcing every player to fit one rigid system, we need to:
✅ Coach to different learning styles. Some players learn best by watching, others by doing.
✅ Provide individual feedback. Not every kid responds the same way to corrections.
✅ Encourage self-reflection. Instead of telling a player what went wrong, ask them "What did you see there?"

3. Building Relationships & Player Confidence

📚 Great teachers build trust before they teach.
🏒 Great coaches should do the same.

A coach who yells without building a relationship loses the room. But a coach who shows players they care creates a team that wants to learn and improve.

✅ Ask players for their thoughts instead of just giving instructions.
✅ Get to know players beyond hockey—what motivates them, what they enjoy.
✅ Use positive reinforcement. Instead of "Don’t do that," say "Try this next time."

📌 Key Takeaway: If players don’t trust or respect you, they won’t listen to you. Build relationships first, coach second.

3️. What Needs to Change in USA Hockey’s Coaching Education?

To truly improve coaching education, USA Hockey needs to:

1. Integrate Learning Science into Coaching Courses

🔹 Teach how kids learn at different ages and how to engage them effectively.
🔹 Emphasize short, structured learning segments instead of long lectures.
🔹 Provide resources on player psychology and confidence-building.

2. Prioritize Communication & Relationship-Building

🔹 Train coaches in effective feedback methods.
🔹 Teach how to ask questions, engage players, and encourage self-reflection.
🔹 Focus on how to build trust with players before teaching skills.

3. Move Beyond Drills – Teach Coaches How to Coach

🔹 Include modules on differentiated instruction (coaching to different learning styles).
🔹 Encourage two-way communication between players and coaches.
🔹 Provide real-world coaching scenarios that focus on teaching, not just running drills.

🏆 Conclusion: Coaching is Teaching – It’s Time for USA Hockey to Act Like It

📌 Right now, USA Hockey’s coaching education focuses too much on systems and not enough on actual teaching methods.

✅ We need to train coaches on how kids learn, not just what to teach.
✅ We need to emphasize communication, feedback, and relationships.
✅ We need to build a coaching culture that develops players as learners, not just athletes.

If USA Hockey truly wants to develop great players, it needs to start by developing great teachers.

FOLLOW US ON SOCIAL MEDIA!